Artisan Bakery · Est. New York

What does a cake taste like when it's made with love?

At Caroline's Cake Shop, every layer tells a story. We craft bespoke celebration cakes and delicate pastries by hand on Broadway — because your sweetest moments deserve nothing less.

Explore Our Cakes Find Us
C
W
B

Trusted by hundreds of New York celebrations

An elegant multi-tiered celebration cake on a marble pedestal at Caroline's Cake Shop

Handcrafted

With premium ingredients

Scroll
A baker carefully decorating a custom cake
An elegant display of assorted pastries and desserts
A beautiful cake being sliced at a celebration
Fresh pastries coming out of the oven
Our Story

A passion for baking,
rooted in New York.

Caroline's Cake Shop has been a beloved presence on Broadway, crafting unforgettable sweets for New York's most cherished moments. Every creation begins with a conversation — about your occasion, your flavors, your vision.

We source the finest ingredients, from Madagascar vanilla to Belgian chocolate, and apply years of technique to every tier, every swirl, every detail. The result is cake that doesn't just look extraordinary — it tastes like it should.

100%

Handcrafted daily

Premium

Imported ingredients

Bespoke

Made to your design

What We Make

Our Signature Specialties

From elegant wedding tiers to weekend treat boxes, every item is baked fresh and finished by hand.

An elegant multi-tiered wedding cake with gold accents

Celebration Cakes

Weddings, birthdays, anniversaries — bespoke tiered cakes designed around your occasion and taste preferences.

A colorful assortment of artisan macarons

Artisan Pastries

Macarons, éclairs, tarts, and petit fours — each one a small work of confectionery art, baked fresh each morning.

A beautifully poured latte alongside a pastry

Coffee & Café

Specialty coffee, espresso drinks, and seasonal infusions — the perfect companion to any of our baked goods.

Rich chocolate dessert with gold leaf decoration

Chocolate Creations

Truffles, ganache cakes, chocolate-dipped treats — for those who believe chocolate is its own language of indulgence.

An elegant display of decorated cupcakes

Cupcakes & Treat Boxes

Perfect for office gatherings, gifts, or a little weekend indulgence — available in curated boxes and custom flavors.

A stunning dessert table spread for a special event

Event Dessert Tables

Full dessert table design for your event — coordinated flavors, styles, and presentations that elevate any celebration.

Visit Us

Come Say Hello

Whether you're stopping in for a coffee and a pastry or planning a bespoke celebration cake, we'd love to welcome you to our shop on Broadway.

Address

4484 Broadway
New York, NY 10040

Hours

Mon – Sat: 8:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Sunday: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Planning a special occasion?

Call us to discuss your custom cake — we love bringing your vision to life.

Call (516) 555-5556

Send Us a Message

Have a question or want to discuss a custom order?

Is this your business? Claim your website
Your own domain includedLive in minutes, edit anytime
Claim my website